First Cobalt, last man standing in N. American cobalt sector?

all figures in US$ unless indicated otherwise

Glencore & First Cobalt achieve important milestone

First Cobalt Corp. (TSX-V: FCC) / (OTCQX: FTTSF) announced it has entered into a $5 million loan facility with Glencore to complete advanced engineering, metallurgical testing, field work & permitting associated with the recommissioning & expansion of its 100%-owned cobalt Refinery in Canada. The loan facility bears interest of LIBOR + 5%, and has a two-year term, extendable by one year, at the company’s election.

The First Cobalt Refinery (the “Refinery“) is a hydrometallurgical facility in the Canadian Cobalt Camp of Ontario, Canada, roughly 600 km from the U.S. border. It’s the only permitted primary cobalt (“Co“) refinery in N. America. It can produce either a Co sulfate for lithium-ion batteries or a Co metal for the aerospace industry. This is a long-lasting, very valuable, hard asset with decades of use ahead of it.

Upon completion of a positive Definitive Feasibility Study (“DFS“) for a 55 tonnes per day (“tpd“) facility, and subject to other terms & conditions, Glencore has agreed to advance an additional $40 million in three stages. However, not all of the $45 million in funding will necessarily be needed. A 30% contingency is built into that figure.

On September 4th the company announced it has awarded key contracts to complete DFS on a 55-tpd operation. Field work commences this month, with expected delivery of a DFS in Q1 2020. Ausenco Engineering is leading the effort, supported by SGS for advanced metallurgical test work, Knight Piésold for tailings studies and Story Environmental for environmental & permitting.

Glencore will provide technical support through its affiliate, Expert Process Solutions. Deliverables from these esteemed groups include a NI 43-101 compliant DFS on a 55-tpd refinery restart and a Pre-Feasibility Study (“PFS“) on a 12-tpd interim operating scenario. {note: a conference call will be held on Sept. 9th, details to follow}

Three-phased approach to get the Refinery up to 55-tpd (5,020 tonnes/yr. Co sulphate) in 2021

In Phase one, the initial loan amount will be used to assess the suitability of the Refinery to treat Glencore-sourced material under a long-term supply agreement to produce Co sulphate for the N. American EV market.

Also in Phase one is the completion of advanced engineering & estimating, metallurgical testing, fieldwork & permitting — including delivery of a PFS for a 12-tpd recommissioning next year, and a DFS for an expansion to 55-tpd.

Phase two entails the actual recommissioning of the Refinery by late next year, under existing permits, at a feed rate of 12-tpd. This will allow the parties to pre​-​qualify ​products with customers in the EV ​supply chain.

Phase three contemplates an expansion from 12-tpd to 55-tpd in 2021, using existing buildings & infrastructure.

Ausenco scoping-study shows attractive Refinery economics

An Ausenco conceptual study for the First Cobalt Refinery Restart Project (available on the company’s website) estimated that using hydroxide feed grading 30% Co, at 55-tpd throughput, the Refinery could produce 5,020 tonnes/yr. (11.067 million pounds) of cobalt sulphate.

That would be a meaningful proportion of total finished (refined) Co coming from friendly, reliable, safe countries. It’s estimated that 5,020 tonnes/yr. would be about 5% of global refined Co supply. So, the Refinery would be a globally significant suppler, and even more so in N. America, as soon as 2021.

At the current (September 2nd) Co price of $16.10/lb., 5,020 tonnes would generate annualized gross revenue of ~$178 million. Importantly, Ausenco recently lowered its operating cost estimate contained in their scoping study by about 30% due to lower reagent costs. Therefore, annual op-ex at 55-tpd is now expected to be ~$25.4 million.

Cobalt prices up ~35% in past month on Glencore mine closure news

Each $1/lb. change in the Co price amounts to nearly C$15 million in annualized gross revenue at the Refinery level. According to, the Co price is up $4.3 to $16.10/lb., from its 52-week low of $11.8/lb. That increase would equate to ~$47.7 million in incremental revenue. Yet, despite the Co price being up ~37%, First Cobalt’s share price is up just 12.5% from its low of C$0.12 to C$0.135.

As the Refinery project continues to be de-risked, there could be a nice move upwards in the share price. First Cobalt could be one of the best remaining pure-play bets on Co prices, certainly one of the very best, if not the best, N. American junior.

Trent Mell, First Cobalt’s president & CEO, commented,

“We are delighted to be working with Glencore to bring a domestic supply of battery-grade Cobalt to the N. American market. Subject to results over the next six months, first production is targeted for late 2020, followed by the commissioning of an expanded 55-tpd facility in 2021. Cobalt prices have increased considerably over the past several weeks and the outlook for the EV market remains exceptionally strong.”

Experts like Benchmark Mineral Intelligence are calling for significant increases in demand for cobalt, lithium & graphite in the early 2020s, when hundreds of new EV models hit the road.

I asked senior cobalt analyst Caspar Rawles of Benchmark for his view on the news of Glencore shutting the Mutanda mine. Mutanda is the world’s largest Co/Cu mine, accounting for approx. 20% of cobalt supply.

“The Glencore announcement is significant, the reaction has seen prices rise by ~35% for some cobalt products. This increase might sound significant, but it has just seen prices pushed back in to the historical range in most cases. Whilst the market has reacted, there is no change to supply in the near term, as the closure doesn’t take place until year end.

This closure, assuming it happens, would pull Benchmark’s forecasted supply deficit forward by 12-18 months. That, in turn, could lead to higher pricing sooner than many were expecting. However, the exact impact won’t be known until we see how other producers in the industry reacts to the shutdown.”

Low cobalt prices are the cure to low cobalt prices….

In a recent article, Eurasian Resources Group’s (“ERG“) senior management stated that at the current cobalt price, 20% to 30% of global mine supply is at risk of disappearing next year. They say that in the longer-term, US$20+/lb. is required to attract much-needed capital to the industry.

On top of the huge Glencore / Mutanda mine shutdown news, in mid-August, Reuters reported that China’s largest cobalt refiner Zhejiang Huayou Cobalt’s overseas unit is pulling out of a deal to invest in a cobalt mine in the DRC. In July, reported that production of hand-dug cobalt (artisanal mining) in the DRC is falling due to the plunge in Co prices.

Thousands of artisanal miners are said to be switching their focus to copper. In addition to much lower cobalt prices, mining cost inflation (such as sulphuric acid) and higher taxes in the DRC are kicking in to squeeze profits.

Payback of Glencore debt over six years from 2022?

There will be some sort of revenue or profit split between First Cobalt & Glencore, the terms of which are still being negotiated. In a tolling scenario I estimate that debt advanced to the company could be paid off in six years, 2022-2027 ($7.5 million/yr.).

That assumes First Cobalt retains 25% of the economics until the debt is repaid. I assume a $20/lb. Co price, cobalt sulphate production of 11.067 million pounds/yr., $25.4 million in operating expenses, 95% recoveries and a 70% payable rate on feedstock costs.


What more can I say? First Cobalt is one of the only companies moving forward in a battery metals market where investment sentiment is very weak. Not just for cobalt, but lithium, graphite & vanadium as well.

However, unlike so many battery metals peers with cap-ex hurdles in the hundreds of millions or billion dollar+ ranges, First Cobalt is fully-funded through commercial production in 4Q 2020 and maintains 100% ownership of its valuable primary cobalt refinery.

Glencore is not busy de-risking or funding a lot of other junior cobalt companies / assets, but it’s strongly backing First Cobalt Corp. (TSX-V: FCC) / (OTCQX: FTTSF) on the Refinery. That says a lot about the long-term value of this key strategic facility in N. America.

DisclosuresThe content of this article is for information only. Readers fully understand and agree that nothing contained herein, written by Peter Epstein of Epstein Research [ER](together, [ER]) about First Cobalt Corp., including but not limited to, commentary, opinions, views, assumptions, reported facts, calculations, etc. is to be considered implicit or explicit investment advice. Nothing contained herein is a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security. [ER] is not responsible for investment actions taken by the reader. [ER] has never been, and is not currently, a registered or licensed financial advisor or broker/dealer, investment advisor, stockbroker, trader, money manager, compliance or legal officer, and does not perform market making activities. [ER] is not directly employed by any company, group, organization, party or person. The shares of First Cobalt Corp. are highly speculative, not suitable for all investors. Readers understand and agree that investments in small cap stocks can result in a 100% loss of invested funds. It is assumed and agreed upon by readers that they will consult with their own licensed or registered financial advisors before making any investment decisions.

At the time this interview was posted, Peter Epstein owned shares of First Cobalt Corp., and the Company was an advertiser on [ER]. 

While the author believes he’s diligent in screening out companies that, for any reasons whatsoever, are unattractive investment opportunities, he cannot guarantee that his efforts will (or have been) successful. [ER] is not responsible for any perceived, or actual, errors including, but not limited to, commentary, opinions, views, assumptions, reported facts & financial calculations, or for the completeness of this article or future content. [ER] is not expected or required to subsequently follow or cover any specific events or news, or write about any particular company or topic. [ER] is not an expert in any company, industry sector or investment topic.